Comparison

Comparing 99Designs Vs Graphic Design Eye LLC for Business Owners

The choice between 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye comes down to one core question: do you need a crowd of fresh concepts from many designers, or a dedicated creative partner who already knows your brand? Here's an honest, side-by-side look at both.

Get A Demo Contact Us

5.4K+ Projects Delivered

24H Standard Turnaround

Fixed Sub & Project Based

$0 Hidden Fees

Head To Head

99Designs vs Graphic Design Eye At a Glance

Use this table for a quick overview before reading the full breakdown below.

Factor

Service Model

Pricing Model

Manager Assignment

Design Concepts

Turnaround Time

Revision Policy

Service Types

Communication

Money-Back

Best For

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Agency as a Service

Subscription & project-based or custom project quotes

A dedicated manager for every project

Multiple contest submissions to choose from

1–2 business days

Unlimited revisions included

Logo, branding, digital, web, print, social media, photo editing, more

Chat directly with your dedicated manager in your dashboard

100% money-back guarantee

Any business

99Designs

Freelance marketplace/contest platform

Per-project / contest packages (one-off)

Not available

Multiple concepts from many designers

5–10+ days for contests

Varies by package/designer agreement

Logo, branding, web, print, packaging, more

Platform messaging with multiple designers

Contest offers a money-back guarantee

One-off projects, logo design, wide concepts

Graphic Design Eye LLC BEST VALUE

$49

/starting

Service Model AaaS

Pricing Model Sub & Project-Based

Manager Dedicated Manager

Concepts Multiples

Turnaround 1–2 Business Days

Revision Policy Unlimited revisions

Service Types 120+

Communication Chat Dashboard

Money-Back 100%

Best For Any Business

99Designs

/starting

Service Model Marketplace

Pricing Model Contest

Manager Not available

Concepts Many Designers

Turnaround 5–10+ days for contests

Revision Policy Varies by Package

Service Types 120+

Communication Platform Chat

Guarantee Contest offers a money-back guarantee

Best For Contest

Feature

Key Differences Between 99Designs vs
Graphic Design Eye

Numbers and checkmarks in a table only tell part of the story. The sections below break down the seven dimensions that matter most when comparing 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye.

1. Design Output and Service Breadth

How a design service generates its output shapes everything: the quality of individual assets, the consistency of your brand over time, and the creative value you get for your money. 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye take fundamentally different approaches to this. One runs on competition and volume; the other on commitment and context. That distinction is where every decision begins.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Problem-first design approach on every project
Design starts with brand context, goals, and strategy
Built-in brand knowledge; outcome-driven from day one
120+ service areas across the full marketing stack
All services available on every subscription tier

99Designs

Request-first execution; design begins after brief submission
Contest model delivers 30–100+ concepts from diverse designers
Brand interpretation is limited in contest submissions
Broad category coverage: logo, web, print, packaging, apparel
Premium categories may require higher-tier contest packages

2. Pricing and Plan Structure

Pricing is rarely just a number. It signals how a service is structured, who it serves, and what kind of working relationship it supports. A per-project fee works well for businesses with occasional, defined design needs. A subscription model fits those with ongoing creative demands. Picking the wrong one doesn't just cost money; it creates friction that builds up across every project and every quarter.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Flat-rate monthly subscription; fully predictable costs
Project-based pricing available for one-off engagements
All 120+ services included in the entry-level plan
No per-project fees eroding your design budget
Most cost-effective for businesses with continuous design needs

99Designs

Per-project or contest-based pricing; pay per deliverable
Contest packages: Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum tiers
1-to-1 projects priced per designer's rate and scope
Costs multiply quickly across simultaneous projects
Best value for infrequent, clearly scoped one-off work

3. Designer Assignment and Ongoing Relationship

A designer who knows your brand is worth more than one who is simply talented. Brand knowledge builds with every brief, every revision, every approved asset. It closes the gap between what you envision and what actually gets delivered. So, does the service you're evaluating have a way to build and hold onto that knowledge, or does it start from scratch every time?

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Single dedicated manager assigned from day one
Manager builds deep brand familiarity across every project
Real-time communication on the platform dashboard
No repeated brand briefings; consistent voice and style
Long-term relationship supports evolving brand needs

99Designs

Contest: work with many designers simultaneously
1-to-1: hire a single freelancer, but no ongoing guarantee
Platform-mediated communication with each designer
Brand context must be re-briefed for each new project
No continuity unless you re-hire the same freelancer

4. Turnaround Time

In today’s business environment, the gap between briefing a design and receiving a finished, approved asset is not a minor operational detail. It's a competitive variable. Product launches, campaign windows, investor presentations, and retail deadlines are all time-sensitive. A service that delivers in one to two days operates in a fundamentally different strategic register from one that routinely takes five to ten. Speed, when reliable, is a business advantage.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Standard: 1–2 business days per deliverable
Direct communication accelerates revision cycles significantly
Brand familiarity reduces briefing and correction time

99Designs

Design contests typically run 5–10+ days for submissions
1-to-1 projects are faster; timelines depend on the freelancer
Multiple revision rounds can extend the total project duration
Rush options available on some packages at an added cost

5. Design Quality and Consistency

Quality is one of the most misused words in design. It gets thrown around to mean visual polish, but for businesses building a brand, it demands more than that: work that looks right, sounds right, and feels right across every channel, every format, and every audience interaction.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Consistent quality from a single brand-familiar manager
Outcome-driven approach aligned with business objectives
Quality improves over time as the manager learns the brand
Strong coverage: branding, print, digital, web, social media

99Designs

Quality varies widely across the designer pool
Contest model surfaces diverse styles, not a consistent brand voice
Top-tier designers available at higher contest package tiers
Quality control relies on client selection from submissions

6. Communication and Workflow

Who handles your design matters; how easily you can reach them matters more. Creative output is only as good as the communication behind it. A brilliant brief, poorly received, yields mediocre work. A revision stuck in a queue stalls an entire project. That connection shapes everything that follows.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Direct messaging with your dedicated manager in the dashboard
All communication via the Graphic Design Ey platform interface
Personalised onboarding aligned to brand and business goals
Fast feedback loops; platform queuing or ticket systems
Multi-seat and team access options available

99Designs

All communication via the 99Designs platform interface
Contest: brief and rate submissions from multiple designers
1-to-1: direct messaging with the selected freelancer
Project management tools built into the platform dashboard

7. Revisions Policy

Revisions are where a design service's true cost often shows itself. A generous revision policy signals confidence in the process and a genuine investment in delivering work that actually satisfies. A restrictive one, whether through capped rounds or added charges, quietly poisons the creative process. Clients start self-censoring. Notes go unraised. The final asset lands slightly off, and nobody says anything.

Graphic Design Eye LLC

Unlimited revisions included on all plans
Direct manager access speeds up iteration significantly
Brand familiarity reduces unnecessary revisions over time

99Designs

Revision rounds vary by package tier and designer agreement
Contest winners may offer limited revisions post-selection
1-to-1 projects: revisions negotiated with the freelancer

Decision guide

Which Service Is Right for Your Business?

There's no single right answer. The best service comes down to your design needs, budget, and how much brand consistency matters to you. Use the guidance below to decide with confidence.

Choose Graphic Design Eye LLC If

Your business is growing and needs a consistent brand voice across every touchpoint: digital, print, social, web, and packaging.
Your marketing team needs a reliable stream of design assets without the overhead of juggling freelancers or running repeated contests.
You're building a brand identity from scratch and want a long-term creative relationship, not a pile of disconnected concepts to pick from.
You need predictable monthly design costs with no billing surprises.
Fast iteration and direct communication with your designer are critical to how you work.
You've outgrown one-off freelance work. What you need now is an integrated design partner who knows your brand as well as you do.

Choose 99Designs If

You're launching a brand for the first time and want to explore a wide range of logo or identity concepts before locking in a creative direction.
Your design needs are genuinely infrequent: a single campaign, an annual rebrand, or a one-off packaging project.
The project calls for maximum creative diversity, such as product branding or exploratory packaging concepts where broad inspiration is the goal.
You have the time and willingness to manage a contest process and review multiple submissions from a global pool of designers.
You're a startup or individual with a clearly scoped, one-time brief and a set project budget.
You want to browse and choose from a vetted global marketplace of professional designers.

Testimonial

Real Clients. Real Results. Real Confidence.

Clients who move away from freelance work or contest-based design tend to notice the same shift: fewer revision cycles, faster delivery, and brand collateral that grows more coherent over time. The relationship model works because brand knowledge, once built, keeps paying off.

"Maybe some person-to-person interaction, as everything was done via email, and could have been easier at times on the phone."

Dan Glavin

"The edited images I received back were so beautiful!!! The best deep etching I have ever seen. The results are flawless. I needed garments on a mannequin deep-etched with the base excluded. I am..."

Andrew Ogterop

Photographer

"The team at Graphic Eye Design did a masterful job providing compelling design alternatives for my upcoming book cover. They were patient, thoughtful, respectful and courteous. Above all, they were..."

Ed Hawkins

Climate Scientist

"Fast and effcient service, good quality, fair price, will use again"

Phil Green

Business Owner

"They were very professional, responded quickly and were very accommodating to our needs. Will highly recommend."

Alejandra

Stewart Elementary

"Our Nonprofit organization needed a vector file created for print. Graphic Design Eye took our image logo and fixed it perfectly for our needs. Their turnaround time was super fast, plus they..."

Resa Gary

Software Developer

"Great Service, they took in my ideas and responded quickly and accordingly."

Mauricio Guerra

Owner

"Graphic Design Eye are a wonderful company to work with. They helped Africa Health Organisation (AHO) by designing its marketing materials such as Profile, Brochure, Flyer and Poster. Our staff and..."

Graciano Masauso

CEO

"The logo design was fantastic. It represents my business very much. I couldn't think that I will get that kind of meaningful work for my branding design. I'm greatly going to recommend this..."

Rane Adms

Director

"I'm one of their oldest customers. I have used this place for more than 4 years and love their working very much. They always pleased me with different kinds of amazing designs and editing! Thanks..."

Dane Butler

Company

Frequently Asked Questions

99Designs vs Graphic Design Eye FAQs

99Designs runs on contests. Graphic Design Eye LLC runs on commitment. Below are the most frequently asked questions about both services.

99Designs is a crowdsourcing platform where designers compete by submitting concepts through contests. Graphic Design Eye works differently; it's a dedicated agency service with direct communication and a personal project manager built into your dashboard. One gives you variety through competition, the other gives you a committed, creative partner who actually knows your brand.

99Designs is built for one-off or project-based work. Even with a Pro subscription, you don't get a dedicated manager who learns your brand over time. If you need consistent, ongoing design output, a subscription service like Graphic Design Eye is the stronger fit.

Yes, Graphic Design Eye assigns a dedicated manager to every engagement from day one, regardless of plan tier. This lets the manager build real familiarity with your brand, which means more consistent, faster, and accurate design work with each new project.

99Designs shines when you want to explore logo concepts. Its contest model brings in multiple diverse ideas for clients to compare and choose from. Graphic Design Eye is the better fit when your logo needs to live within a larger brand identity, where visual consistency across the whole system is what matters most.

Graphic Design Eye turns around work in one to two business days, and direct communication with your manager keeps revisions moving fast. 99Designs contests, on the other hand, typically run five to ten days or longer. If you need production-ready work quickly, Graphic Design Eye is the clear choice.

Revisions on 99Designs vary by package tier and designer agreement, with contest winners typically offering a set number of rounds. Graphic Design Eye, on the other hand, includes unlimited revisions across all plans, making iteration faster and cost-free.

Graphic Design Eye specialises in e-commerce image editing, covering services like clipping path, ghost mannequin, colour correction, background removal, and retouching. These aren't a focus area for 99Designs, which is built around graphic design briefs and creative contests rather than production-level image editing.

Businesses that produce multiple design assets each month will usually get more value from Graphic Design Eye's flat rate subscription or per project pricing, since the cost per asset tends to run lower than what 99Designs charges for individual projects or contests. That said, 99Designs is the stronger choice for occasional, well-defined one-off projects where the creative brief is clear from the start.

Graphic Design Eye is built around direct, one-on-one communication with a dedicated manager from start to finish. 99Designs routes everything through its platform interface, which works well for managing contest submissions but puts structural distance between the client and the designer doing the actual work.

Graphic Design Eye suits businesses that want consistent branding, a long-term creative partner, and steady refinement from someone who already knows their brand. 99Designs is a better fit for brands that want to quickly explore a wide range of styles through a competitive submission process.

Yes, both 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye offer brochure and catalogue design services. Graphic Design Eye leans more toward production-ready, marketing-focused layouts; assets built to drive real business outcomes, not just look good on a page.

CASE STUDIES

From Brief to Beautiful, Our Client
Success Stories

Knowing the difference between 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye is useful. Seeing that difference play out in real brand challenges, with measurable results, is something else entirely. Graphic Design Eye's case studies cover e-commerce, SaaS, retail, professional services, and hospitality. Each one shows what a dedicated creative partnership actually looks like in practice, and what it delivers commercially.

How Better Design Improved Brand Performance

How Better Photo Editing Helped Eibach Sell More Car Parts

How Strategic Design Built a Premium T-Shirt Brand

View All Case Studies

Ready to Work With a Design Partner Who Knows Your Brand?

Take the first step today. Explore subscription plans and packages, request a custom quote, or speak directly with a creative client director about your brand's specific needs.

Place Order Today!

Receive Tomorrow!

Start Your Subscription

Pick A Price Plan

Comparing 99Designs Vs Graphic Design Eye LLC for Business Owners

99Designs vs Graphic Design Eye At a Glance

Key Differences Between 99Designs vs Graphic Design Eye

1. Design Output and Service Breadth

2. Pricing and Plan Structure

3. Designer Assignment and Ongoing Relationship

4. Turnaround Time

5. Design Quality and Consistency

6. Communication and Workflow

7. Revisions Policy

Which Service Is Right for Your Business?

Choose Graphic Design Eye LLC If

Choose 99Designs If

Real Clients. Real Results. Real Confidence.

99Designs vs Graphic Design Eye FAQs

What is the main difference between 99Designs and Graphic Design Eye?

Is 99Designs good for ongoing design work?

Does Graphic Design Eye offer a dedicated designer and manager?

Which creative service is better for logo design?

Which service is faster for urgent design projects?

Can I get unlimited revisions with 99Designs?

Which platform is better for photo editing and clipping path services?

Which service is more affordable for ongoing design needs?

Which service offers more personalised client communication?

Which service is better for custom branding projects?

Can both companies handle brochure and catalogue design?

From Brief to Beautiful, Our Client Success Stories

Ready to Work With a Design Partner Who Knows Your Brand?

Key Differences Between 99Designs vs
Graphic Design Eye

From Brief to Beautiful, Our Client
Success Stories